Music Review

Book Reviews and Reading Diary
CD Buying Guide and Music Links
Best-of lists
CD Reviews
CDs, sorted by Style
CDs, sorted by year issued
CDs, sorted by publication review ran in
CDs by San Diego bands
All CDs, sorted by band name
All CDs, sorted by album title
Favorite quotations
Contact Me

Older, wiser and still very hip

Gimcracks and Gewgaws
Gimcracks and Gewgaws
By Mose Allison

Blue Note Records: 1998

Right on My Way Home
Right on My Way Home
By Bob Dorough

Blue Note Records: 1997

These reviews first appeared in the April 18, 1978 edition of the American Reporter.

It's got to be more than karma that has Blue Note releasing new albums by Mose Allison and Bob Dorough within a few months of each other. Surely somebody at the venerable jazz label saw the ... well, rightness, of having two of the most distinctive stylists of the singer/songwriter school hitting the streets at the same time.

Fame and fortune haven't graced either to date, although Allison has enjoyed moderate success in jazz circles. Dorough has remained a cult figure, better known for his songwriting (the jazz standard "I've Got Just About Everything," songs from the Saturday-morning children's TV show "Schoolhouse Rock").

They're both over 70 now, each well into his sixth decade of performing. They're also both at the peak of their skills. Neither was ever a piano powerhouse like Art Tatum or Oscar Peterson, so any slight decline in coordination or dexterity due to age would be irrelevant.

What sets these two pianist/singers apart is their style, their sly takes on life. What writer Mitchell Feldman writes of Dorough in his liner notes – that he is "a member of the fraternity of witty songwriters that includes Hoagy Carmichael, Johnny Mercer, Harold Arlen" – applies equally well to Allison.

On their new releases, Allison provides us with a full dozen new songs; Dorough contributes three of the ten tracks on his. Their fascination with words has not dimmed; has grown sharper, in fact.

From Allison, we get this passage from his song "What Will It Be":

What will it be, the thing that actually kills you
Will it be the thing that thrills you
What will you have that puts you in your casket
Will you up and blow a gasket
Maybe you'll get lucky and go out in your sleep
Either way, it's safe to say that's one promise you're bound to keep.

And from Dorough's "Right on My Way Home":

If you call from some hole in the wall in Nepal I will follow
Just to give in to you I'd go to India too
If you beckon from Temeka I'll be neck 'n' neck behind you
Fly air express Marakesh where I guess there I'd get you
Because it's rights on my way home
Any which way you roam
It's right on my way home.

Both are, as mentioned, highly individualistic singers, with high voices and offbeat pacing – although they are similar to each other only in their equal dissimilarity to the norm. (Although pop singer Randy Newman, he of "Short People" fame, was obviously and equally influenced by both men.) So even when they're singing somebody else's song – Dorough handling "Moon River" or Allison on "St. Louis Blues" – it is still done up in their respective inimitable style.

They're national resources, Bob Dorough and Mose Allison. The fact that they're not well-known is as much our loss as theirs. The fact that both men continue in good health and creative force into their latter years is a blessing that smart music fans will take advantage of.